How to Keep From Overselling or Underestimating the United Nations
Mark P. Lagon and David Shorr
Stanley Foundation program officer David Shorr and Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for International Organizations Mark Lagon resist both the skeptics and boosters of the United Nations by pointing toward appropriate expectations for the world body, and other intergovernmental forums. They counter the perception of the United Nations as primarily an instrument of international law, but also stress the importance of politics and diplomacy within international organizations for the reinforcement of a rules-based order. The so-called “court of world opinion” is not actually a court. At the same time, though, the international norms that emerge from the political (and sometimes legal) process are critical to the promotion of peace, freedom, and prosperity.
The authors examine the emerging concept of the sovereignty of national governments as a responsibility and the current state of the norm of noninterference in internal affairs of UN member states. National governments are the “owners” of international organizations such as the United Nations, and their political will is the animating force of any collective action. Yet the UN Charter also promise the citizens of the world’s nations that its ideals will be felt in their day-to-day lives, and governments must be accountable for the treatment of their own people, particularly when it comes to the most severe abuses. New mechanisms and norms such as the Human Rights Council and the responsibility to protect were developed with this in mind.
Since the United Nations is a creature of its member states, their expectations for the world body effectively establish its possibilities and limits. The world’s intergovernmental bodies offer mechanisms to set agendas, agree on fundamental approaches, decide on courses of action, and implement programs to deal with the entire range of international problems. The world community needs vehicles for actions on which they can agree, but they have to muster the political will to agree in the first place. The authors pinpoint the political dysfunctions of the United Nations and offer recommendations for how they can be corrected.
This document is part of the Stanley Foundation's "Bridging the Foreign Policy Divide" series.
Our new bimonthly newsletter is filled with resources to keep you up-to-date with our work at the Stanley Foundation. Each edition includes news about recent publications and stories as well as features our people and partners.
You’ll also find many extras, from upcoming events to multimedia resources. Sign up for the latest to stay engaged on key global issues!
A quarterly publication, Courier provokes thought on world affairs by giving readers insight into issues driving foundation programming. Winter 2013 issue PDF (287 KB)
Subscribe for FREE
The Stanley Foundation publishes policy briefs, analytical articles, and reports on a number of international issues.
|New Stanley Foundation President
The Stanley Foundation Board of Directors has elected Keith Porter to be president and chief executive officer, effective immediately. Press Release.
|53rd Strategy for Peace Conference
|How Summit Meetings Build Multilateral Cooperation
This event gave expert presenters an opportunity to preview the upcoming G-8, G-20, and NATO Summits' issues, significance, and likely outcomes. Video of this event.
A new Now Showing event-in-a-box toolkit Before the Killing Begins: The Politics of Mass Violence considers how early preventive strategies by governments and the international community should build much-needed capacities within countries, and make it harder for leaders to resort to violence. It aims to encourage discussion of how future efforts might better protect populations under threat, giving new resolve to the promise of never again. Sign Up
|Watch and Learn
Stanley Foundation events, talks, video reports, and segments from our Now Showing event-in-a-box series can now be viewed on YouTube. To receive regular updates on our video posts, please subscribe today.