The Stanley Foundation
Menu
Close
Seeking a secure peace with freedom and justice, built on global citizenship and effective global governance.
Search 
October 14, 2008

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE

Contact: Sean Harder, 563-264-1500

New Understanding of Security Threats
Must Drive Rethink of US Nuclear Weapons Policy

Muscatine, Iowa – A changing US strategic policy must be driven by a new understanding of the security threats facing the United States and the relative strengths and weaknesses in the measures adopted to meet them.

The overall strategic picture is trending along a set of particular pathways, characterized by:

  • Some states moving to reduce the saliency of nuclear weapons.
  • Some states at or moving toward a high saliency of nuclear weapons.
  • Proliferation, both to new states and also to nonstate actors.
  • Inadvertent and accidental diffusion of nuclear technology and materials to additional states and nonstate actors.
  • A thoroughly more robust dispersion of civilian nuclear technology and materials, driven by the global need for new and dramatically larger sources of cheap and carbon-neutral energy.

Current policy will not be sustainable to achieve a secure nuclear future for the United States and the global community, and the United States must couch its nuclear decision making with the above indicators in mind.

A group of nuclear policy experts, academics, and NGO representatives met to discuss these issues at "US Strategic Posture and Conventional Capabilities," a roundtable at the Stanley Foundation's 49th annual Strategy for Peace Conference October 10-12, 2008, at Airlie Center near Warrenton, Virginia.

Issues discussed ranged from the current US nuclear doctrine to what steps the US should take toward continuing its support of a world without nuclear weapons. Stemming from the 2001 US Nuclear Posture Review, participants drew upon areas that need to be underscored looking toward a new administration that will develop its own Nuclear Policy Review in 2009.

Along with the growing realization of the above nuclear indicators, it is also true that military force in the 21st century is headed toward being a smaller subset of US foreign policy, and strategic utility of the unilateral use of force is declining.

In this strategic environment, roundtable participants achieved consensus that the main goal of US strategic policy should be to prevent the use of nuclear weapons, either by state or nonstate actors. Equally true, in this changing security environment, nuclear weapons in 2008 have no military utility, only political utility. The challenge is how to reduce the political utility of nuclear weapons in a manner that is strategically stable.

In order to move toward addressing this strategic environment, participants made a number of concrete recommendations for an incoming administration to consider:

  • As a path toward reducing political saliency, a statement that limits the utility of US nuclear weapons to a weapon of last resort would signal US leadership.
  • Prior to the 2010 NPT Review Conference, a consensus statement by members of the P-5 that relegates nuclear weapons as weapons of defensive last resort would be helpful in providing a leadership role to the global community.
  • A US declaratory statement that circumscribes the purpose of US nuclear weapons, setting the requirements for nuclear forces with a stringent examination of nuclear missions. This will help reduce the saliency of US nuclear weapons and likely to lead to a reduction in strategic forces.
  • As specific opportunities for continuing the downward trend in its overall stockpile, the US should engage Russia on both extending the verification provisions of START and by considering further reductions beyond the levels agreed to in the Moscow Treaty. 
  • A new 2009 NATO Strategic Concept can make a significant contribution toward reducing the salience of nuclear weapons by considering restricting strategic NATO policy to conventional use.
  • A new administration must establish early strategic consultations with Russia and China on matters of strategic stability. As one indication of the immediacy of this need, it should be noted that the Russian strategic policy, including its nuclear policy, is highly contingent on US strategic policy—both conventional and nuclear.
  • As part of the current Triad, a new administration should conduct a thorough scrub of the entire set of missile defense programs for both technical and operational scrutiny.
  • As a new administration considers the future of the nuclear stockpile, it should produce a statement supporting the goal of moving to zero and a stockpile pathway consistent with those aims. Bolstering current US policy, characteristics of this pathway would include a stockpile that is safe, secure, and reliable without adding additional nuclear missions or needing new testing.
  • The lack of congressional knowledge on issues of strategic matters has resulted in a lack of proper oversight of US nuclear policy. New mechanisms should be considered—such as a joint arms control observer group or eventually a more formal structure, such as a Joint Select Committee on Strategic Policy.
  • As the United States encourages the P-5 and the global community to reduce its reliance on nuclear weapons, reducing its own view of nuclear saliency, it must be careful not to replace dependence on nuclear capabilities with conventional capabilities. International opinion and action is oftentimes more dependent, at least in the short term, on US conventional posture than nuclear policy.

Participants also noted several key questions that remain underexamined and ripe areas for future investigation. Among these are:

  • How would the United States practically achieve a change in US nuclear deterrence policy? Organizationally and operationally, what needs to change?
  • What are the operational and technical requirements that must be examined, outlined, and implemented in order to get very low levels of nuclear stockpiles or potentially zero (absolute or virtual)? Stockpile accountancy and dismantlement verification are key.


Working Paper:
Philip Coyle, Senior Advisor, Center for Defense Information, and Todd Fine, Global Zero, "US Nuclear Forces and Conventional Force Alternatives" (working paper)

The Stanley Foundation will release a more comprehensive report on this Strategy for Peace Conference discussion in the coming weeks.

This document summarizes the primary findings developed at the event. Participants neither reviewed nor approved this document. Therefore, it should not be assumed that every participant subscribes to all of its recommendations, observations, and conclusions.


About The Stanley Foundation
The Stanley Foundation seeks a secure peace with freedom and justice, built on world citizenship and effective global governance. It brings fresh voices, original ideas, and lasting solutions to debates on global and regional problems. The foundation is a nonpartisan, private operating foundation, located in Muscatine, Iowa, that focuses on peace and security issues and advocates principled multilateralism. Online at http://www.stanleyfoundation.org/.


About The Stanley Foundation
The Stanley Foundation advances multilateral action to create fair, just, and lasting solutions to critical issues of peace and security. The foundation's work is built on a belief that greater international cooperation will improve global governance and enhance global citizenship. The organization values its Midwestern roots and family heritage as well as its role as a nonpartisan, private operating foundation. The Stanley Foundation does not make grants. Online at www.stanleyfoundation.org.

Share: Email Facebook Twitter
CONTACTS
To request interviews, resources, or to get in touch with an expert for a story, please contact:
Keith Porter
kporter@stanleyfoundation.org
563-264-6863

INTERNATIONAL REPORTING PROJECT

The International Reporting Project (IRP) and the Stanley Foundation collaborated to bring five international journalists to Marrakech, Morocco to report on the Twenty-Second Conference of the Parties (COP22) to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) from November 7-18, 2016. Read their stories.

MEDIA UPDATES

Sign up for media updates from the Stanley Foundation. We'll e-mail you press statements, news releases, and media alerts as they become available.

EVENTS
Current
10/16/17   Focal Points Meeting of the Latin American Network for Genocide and Mass Atrocity Prevention
10/18/17   58th Strategy for Peace Conference
10/30/17   World Conference of Science Journalists: Nuclear Data Journalism Workshop at Planet Labs
Past
10/05/17   Land Use Dialogues: Setting International Policy Objectives for Agriculture Transitions in Pursuit of the 1.5° C Goal
09/22/17   Nonstate Climate Action at COP23 as a Stepping Stone to 2018
HIGHLIGHTS
2017 International Women Authors Event 2017 International Women Authors Event
Pulitzer Prize finalist Laila Lalami, author of “The Moor’s Account,” will be the featured speaker at the 2017 International Women Authors event on November 9 in Rock Island, Illinois.

Courier Courier
As summer winds down, take a look at the new issue of Courier from the Stanley Foundation. The Summer 2017 issue delves into topics including the transition away from coal in Germany, the increased role of cities in global governance, and the crisis in Venezuela. Also in this issue, read about the increased capabilities of 3D printing, and oversight over emerging technologies. Summer 2017 PDF (1,151K) Subscribe for FREE.

Stanley Foundation Annual Conferences Stanley Foundation Annual Conferences
The Stanley Foundation holds two annual conferences, UN Issues and the Strategy for Peace Conference. These bring together experts from the public and private sectors to meet in a distraction-free setting and candidly exchange ideas on pressing foreign policy challenges.

Divided into roundtable talks, the cutting-edge discussions are intended to inspire group consensus and shared recommendations to push forward the debate on the foundation’s key policy areas.


A Climate for Conflict: Stories from Somalia A Climate for Conflict: Stories from Somalia
The Ground Truth Project, New America, and the Stanley Foundation are hosting a Screening of “A Climate for Conflict” and discussion with the creators followed by a panel discussion on Climate Security and Societal Resilience on May 30, 2017.

Somalia today is at a crossroads between a deepening crisis and a path to stability. Photographer and filmmaker Nichole Sobecki and writer Laura Heaton spent 18 months documenting personal stories of Somalia, creating a film, photography, and reporting that vividly illustrate the human consequences and security risks of a changing climate. Read more.

Follow the conversation online with #AClimateforConflict.


Stanley Foundation at 60
On December 12, 1956, the Stanley Foundation was certified as a nonprofit corporation in the state of Iowa, bringing to life an organization dedicated to creating a world in which there is a secure peace with freedom and justice. Sixty years later, the organization continues to pursue and advance that vision as a thriving nonpartisan operating foundation. Moreover, it remains an organization with a professional staff and the involvement of family members who have an ongoing role in shaping its strategy and core values. More.

Receive Materials Receive Materials
The Stanley Foundation publishes policy briefs, analytical articles, and reports on a number of international issues. To reduce our carbon footprint and cut waste, we almost exclusively, use electronic distribution for our publications. Sign up to receive our resources via e-mail.

the latest the latest
Our bimonthly newsletter is filled with resources to keep you up to date with our work at the Stanley Foundation. Each edition includes news about recent publications and stories as well as features our people and partners.

You will also find many extras, from upcoming events to multimedia resources. Sign up for the latest to stay engaged on key global issues.


Watch and Learn Watch and Learn
Stanley Foundation events, talks, video reports, and segments from our Now Showing event-in-a-box series can now be viewed on YouTube. To receive regular updates on our video posts, please subscribe today.